community power

community power
Max Weber defined power as ‘the chance of … men to realise their own will in a communal action even against the resistance of others who are participating in the action’. This definition is disputed and a major contribution to competing theories of power comes from the community power debate-arguments about how and by whom power is exerted in local democratic polities.
One view is that local power is exercised by an élite -such as local officials, politicians, and leading business interests-and is manifest in its public and private decision-making on public policies (see’s classic Community Power Structure, 1953). However, some political scientists reject this ‘stratification theory’ of power, and deny that an upper-class élite rules, in its own interests, through subordinate officially recognized political and civic leaders. Robert Dahl's study of New Haven (Who Governs), 1961) concludes that the advent of representative democracy shifted power from an élite to various organized interest groups-from oligarchy to pluralism . Differently constituted groups rule depending on the issue in question.
Common to both these approaches is the Weberian action-oriented definition of power: A's power over B amounts to A's ability to compel B to take certain actions. Therefore, in studying community power, we examine decision-making and who influences its outcome. In a much-cited discussion (Power: A Radical View, 1974), Steven Lukes describes this as a one-dimensional view, an approach which Peter Bachrach and Morton S. Baratz (Power and Poverty: Theory and Practice, 1970) deem inadequate. A second dimension to power-so-called ‘non-decisionmaking’-involves the ‘mobilization of bias’, or manipulation of the political agenda by powerful groups, taking decisions which prevent issues from emerging and becoming subject to formal political decision-making.
Lukes also proposes a third dimension to power, ignored by all of the above-mentioned approaches because they are narrowly behavioural, assuming that power must involve decision-making. However, power can also be exercised by preventing people from having grievances in the first place, or as Lukes puts it ‘by shaping their perceptions, cognitions and preferences in such a way that they accept their role in the existing order of things’. Thus, certain issues never arise, so neither do decisions to include or exclude them from the political agenda. Lukes also argues that competing concepts of power reflect differing moral and political values concerning the conception of interests . Power is therefore an ‘essentially contested concept’-subject to irresolvable dispute between theorists with differing values. His radical view denies that interests are simply consciously expressed wants, for these may be shaped by a social system which serves the powerful by suppressing people's recognition of their real interests. (Note the parallel here with the Marxist notion of false consciousness .)
But how can social scientists identify putatively real interests which are unrecognized by those to whom they are attributed? Lukes reanalyses a ‘two-dimensional’ study of community responses to air pollution which, he argues, indicates that real interests can sometimes be identified empirically where counterfactual instances arise, that is, where the processes and structures that deny the expression of real interests are (for whatever reason) temporarily rendered ineffective (a phenomenon illustrated in J. Gaventa's Power and Powerlessness, 1980). His analysis, which has been extensively criticized, transcends the initial confines of the community power debate and addresses the nature of social power generally.
For a summary of the substantive findings of the major studies of community power, together with a report of a sophisticated case-study of local political struggles in a London Borough, see, Urban Politics (1979). See also community studies ; natural experiment.

Dictionary of sociology. 2013.

Игры ⚽ Поможем написать курсовую

Look at other dictionaries:

  • Community radio — is a type of radio service, that offers a third model of radio broadcasting beyond commercial broadcasting and public broadcasting. Community stations can serve geographic communities and communities of interest. They broadcast content that is… …   Wikipedia

  • power — is the concept which is at the heart of the subject of social stratification . It is therefore not surprising that we have seen so many disputes concerning its meaning (including disputes about what particular sociologists meant when they used… …   Dictionary of sociology

  • Power Structure Research — (deutsche Übersetzung: Machtstruktur Forschung) ist ein Zweig der Eliteforschung. Ziel des Power Structure Research ist es, die Macht und Privilegienstrukturen der Machtelite, die formellen und informellen sozialen Netzwerke, in denen sich sehr… …   Deutsch Wikipedia

  • Community organizing — Association of Community Organizations for Reform Now protest (Richir) Community organizing is a process where people who live in proximity to each other come together into an organization that acts in their shared self interest. A core goal of… …   Wikipedia

  • Community wind energy — Wind turbines at Findhorn Ecovillage make the community a net exporter of electricity. Community wind projects are locally owned by farmers, investors, businesses, schools, utilities, or other public or private entities who utilize wind energy to …   Wikipedia

  • Community — For other uses, see Community (disambiguation). A community of interest gathers at Stonehenge, England, for the summer solstice. The term community has two distinct meanings: a group of interacting people, possibly living in close proximity, and… …   Wikipedia

  • community studies — The ambiguities of the term community make any wholly coherent sociological definition of communities, and hence the scope and limits for their empirical study, impossible to achieve. In practice, most self proclaimed community studies have been… …   Dictionary of sociology

  • community — The concept of community concerns a particularly constituted set of social relationships based on something which the participants have in common usually a common sense of identity. It is, to paraphrase Talcott Parsons, frequently used to denote… …   Dictionary of sociology

  • Community of Latin American and Caribbean States — Community of Latin American and Caribbean States. Total population: 591.662 million (2011) Total area: 20.438 million sq km Density: 28.95/sq km The Community of Latin American and Caribbean States (Spanish: Comunidad de Estados Latinoamericanos… …   Wikipedia

  • Community Energy Scotland — Type Charity Registration No. SC SC039673 Founded 2008 Location …   Wikipedia

Share the article and excerpts

Direct link
Do a right-click on the link above
and select “Copy Link”